Skip to content
Home » Creole Seasoning Substitute

Creole Seasoning Substitute

Creole Seasoning Substitute – an exciting topic is at our hands today. So, if you want to learn about the best replacements, read this article. While there’re many substitutes, it’s necessary to choose the right one.

There are a lot of options for creole seasoning. However, you can make your substitute at home with traditional spices if you want to. So, what’s Creole seasoning really?

The creole seasoning combines spices and can be used in several dishes like soups, stews, pasta, etc. Garlic, paprika, oregano, and many other items are in the seasoning mixture.

It’s a pantry staple in various western countries. The reason is that the seasoning gives any savory dish a unique taste burst.

So, now that we know what creole seasoning is, we’ll talk about two different substitutes in this article.

Best Creole Seasoning Substitute

Creole alternative

Cajun and old bay seasoning are the two best alternatives to creole seasoning. Hence, we will share details on these two items with relevant information.

Read the two following sections and see which substitute is better for you.

Cajun Seasoning

A peppery, spicy, and smoky flavor defines a Cajun spice blend. The intensity of the spicy flavor varies according to the measurements of ingredients used.

Note that there’re some minor distinctions between the Creole and the Cajun spice blends. But, we can use them equally in most meals.

Creole seasoning is milder than Cajun seasoning. Therefore you may want to reduce the amount of Cajun seasoning used. Instead, taste the dish and, if required, increase the amount of spice.

If you look correctly, you can find Cajun spice blends in grocery store spice aisles, specialist businesses, and online.

Next, we’ve got another creole seasoning substitute to discuss. It’s the old bay seasoning.

Old Bay Seasoning

Cajun and Creole seasoning mixes can be difficult to make when we don’t have enough time. At that point, old bay seasoning comes to the rescue. The old bay seasoning is easy to make and readily available in the market.

Similar to the creole one, the old bay seasoning uses paprika and cayenne as its two primary ingredients. So, ingredients-wise, these two seasonings are perfect for replacing one another.

One significant factor is that old bay seasoning is perfect for seafood. Also, if you need a flavor like Allspice, this seasoning is just perfect to use.

Reduce the quantity by a third and up the paprika a bit. The flavor profile of your alternative seasoning will be closer to that of an authentic Creole seasoning due to this addition.

However, we’ll not only share the alternatives today. We’ll also talk about the ingredients and processes to make creole seasoning at home. 

Find out how to make creole seasoning in the next part.

Creole Seasoning substitute

Creole Seasoning Substitute

Creole Seasoning Substitute – an exciting topic is at our hands today. So, if you want to learn about the best replacements, read this article. While there’re many substitutes, it’s necessary to choose the right one.


  • Cajun Seasoning
  • Old Bay Seasoning


  • Choose your preferred replacement from the list
  • Add substitute to your recipe
  • Make your own delicious recipe

Homemade Creole Seasoning

So, as promised, we’re here to let you know how to make creole seasoning at home. But, first, we’ll share with you the ingredients necessary.


Paprika, cayenne, and garlic are the three items you must have for the seasoning mix. In addition, black pepper, white pepper, and onion powders are also necessary.

Basil, oregano, and thyme (all dried) are the final items you should have. Now, what about the amount of these items? Find it out next.

  • 1 Tablespoon – Cayenne, Black, and White Pepper.
  • 1 Tablespoon – Onion Powder.
  • 1 Tablespoon – Basil, Oregano, and Thyme
  • 2 Tablespoons- Garlic Powder
  • 2 ½ – 3 Tablespoons- Paprika.

So, these are the items and amounts you’ll need to make ¾ cups of creole seasoning mix.

Now, it’s time to know how to mix these items and make the creole seasoning at home.


Honestly, the method to prepare creole seasoning is easy. But, you need to have the proper ingredients in perfect amounts. So, we’ve given the elements and proportion to make ¾ cup of creole seasoning.

So, if you need to make more than ¾ cup, then adjust the amount of the ingredients accordingly.

  1. A small bowl or pan is best for this. First, add all the ingredients to the pan. Then, mix until they are all combined.
  2. Make sure it is in a sealed jar and keep it in a chilly and dark place for a few days. 
  3. For a hot and spicy mix, double the amount of chilli powder (cayenne pepper). You can also add other spices according to your wish.

And there we go. It’s straightforward to make Creole at home only if you have the right ingredients.

We’ll share some parting words and an exciting question-answers session to finish today’s discussion.

Homemade Creole Seasoning Recipe

Final Words

So, it seems that there’re two perfect creole seasoning substitutes available. One is the Cajun, and the other is the one bay seasoning. These two alternatives are ideal if we consider taste similarity.

Significantly, the Cajun seasoning will give you the same spicy flavor. Considering the one bay seasoning, it’s compliant with many food items, including seafood.

Overall, if we’re to give a verdict among the Cajun and one bay, then the one bay seasoning would be the champion substitute.

If you’ve noticed, we’ve given a straightforward method to make creole seasoning at your home. So don’t worry if you run out of the Creole you’ve bought from a store.

Make the creole seasoning yourself if you have the ingredients. You can read about how to do it in this post.

Now, we’re going to answer some interesting questions about the subject. So please look at each answer and get rid of any more questions you have about them.

Maybe you’d like to read:

FAQs – Creole Seasoning alternative

There can be some additional questions on creole seasoning and its substitutes. We’ve found around seven most common questions people ask on this topic. So, we’ll answer them for you. 

If you’ve any additional questions, you can let us know in the comments.

What is a good substitute for Creole seasoning?

We’ve mentioned two substitutes in this article. They’re the Cajun and the old bay seasoning. Both of the substitutes are just perfect for replacing creole seasoning.

However, if you want us to select one, we prefer the old bay seasoning due to its compatibility with several food items.

Note that, Allspice can be used if you want the highest level of spiciness.

Is Creole Seasoning Spicy?

Yes, Creole seasoning is spicy and has a smoky flavour. The reason people prefer Creole is for their spiciness.

But it all depends on who’s making the seasoning. In addition, there’re different brands of Creole. So, according to brands and the maker, the spiciness level can vary from mild to intense.

Some people make it at their home with lots of additional spices. So, it all depends on the proportions of ingredients used.

Can I substitute Creole seasoning for Old Bay seasoning?

Yes, you can substitute creole seasoning for the old bay. Old bay seasoning is compatible with seafood, soups, stews, and pasta.

So, considering the recipe compatibility, the old bay seasoning is a perfect replacement option.
Also, paprika and cayenne pepper as the base ingredients make old bay seasoning a perfect substitute.

Apart from using old bay and Cajun to replace Creole, you can use homemade spice mixes.

What can I use if I don’t have Creole seasoning?

Cajun and Old bay seasoning are the two best options if you don’t have Creole seasoning.

Also, you can make the creole seasoning if you have the necessary ingredients.

We’ve shown how to make creole seasoning at home in this article. Check if you need to make the seasoning yourself.

Is Creole seasoning the same as Cajun seasoning?

They aren’t the same, but they’ve got a lot of similarities.

A similarity is the presence of cayenne pepper and paprika as ingredients. However, the Cajun is spicier than the Creole seasoning.
On the contrary, Creole’s flavour is more intense due to oregano, thyme, and basil.

What is Creole seasoning made of?

Do you require to know about the Creole seasoning?

Creole seasoning is made from different spices and herbs. Among the herbs oregano and basil are there. Also, thyme adds a great deal of flavour.

Among the spices, paprika, garlic powder, cayenne pepper, and white and black pepper are the notable ones.

Overall, these are the items with which creole seasoning is made. For more information on making the creole seasoning with appropriate ingredients, check back in the article.

We’ve got one last question to answer: the origin of creole seasoning.

Where did Creole Seasoning originate?

The origin of the creole seasoning is thought to be from New Orleans, Louisiana. However, many believe that the idea of the seasoning might well have come from Mexico, Native America, and several countries in Europe.

However, if we are to answer in one word about the origin of the Creole seasoning, it’s the USA (New Orleans, Louisiana).

And with the last section, we’ve ended our discussion on the topic of Creole seasoning substitutes.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating